S1 E5
Status
Ended
Network
Netflix
SEASON
VIEW ALL EPISODE

Season 1  "Premature Theories"  1x5

Aired 3 years ago - Sep 15, 2017

After the documentary goes viral, Peter deals with publicity and sorts through various fan theories. Video evidence from a party provides new clues.

Mouse over thumbnail for slideshow

Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 1
Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 2
I'm the off-campus lunch guy, is what they call me.
Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 3
No one ever listened to me when I hosted the Morning Show,
Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 4
you're fine with that? Cool, thanks. Or how about I tell everyone
Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 5
Free Dylan is now a movement.
Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 6
And there's, like, a bunch of vaginas, too.
Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 7
- Really? - Yeah. Uh, hashtag "Sara Pearson did it,"
Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 8
Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 9
Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 10
It's rumored he's being pushed into early retirement.
Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 11
He did mysteriously discover the spray paint can
Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 12
And a nasty one, too.
Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 13
was based on the penis of her ex-boyfriend,
Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 14
She was down in San Diego with her family, so, I'm not buying this fan theory.
Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 15
at the kegger at Rachel Balducci's grandmother's house,
Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 16
I was chilling, Dylan and the Wayback Boys were right there,
Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 17
Yo, Nana's party was insane.
Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 18
Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 19
Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 20
The boys all deny planning the dicks at Nana's.
Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 21
Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 22
Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 23
Ten fifty-nine, from behind the couch, they're still talking.
Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 24
Hold up. Are we for sure thinking Tuesday, though?
Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 25
"If the cops show up, we just run."
Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 26
When he goes to Ganj and Lucas, we can hear her for a moment.
Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 27
Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 28
by giving him a heart attack.
Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 29
But, "I hope we don't kill him"?
Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 30
Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 31
This brand, Crimpton, was discontinued in 1996.
Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 32
Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 33
Sorry things went like that the other day.
Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 34
That is too good. That's too perfect. He's totally the type of person...
Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 35
Oh, no, no, no. No, no, no, I'm not...
Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 36
Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 37
and while we can't place Dylan with the can,
Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 38
I think if he did the dicks, he's letting it all fall on Dylan.
Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 39
There are a few holes in both timelines, but the entire night is accounted for.
Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 40
Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 41
Gabi. I or Y?
Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 42
We see the can is still in the bushes here at 11:35.
Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 43
- No way. - Yeah!
Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 44
Isn't that the same beer he was drinking earlier?
Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 45
At 12:04, Matt Zordich tries spraying Carl Wolf.
Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 46
Fuck the police!
Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 47
the videos from Nana's party allowed us to narrow our pool of suspects.
Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 48
They have to shake 20 times?
Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 49
we had to shake it again.
Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 50
So, the first car hit would have splatter.

Or scroll and see one by one:

Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 2
I'm the off-campus lunch guy, is what they call me.
#2
Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 3
No one ever listened to me when I hosted the Morning Show,
#3
Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 4
you're fine with that? Cool, thanks. Or how about I tell everyone
#4
Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 5
Free Dylan is now a movement.
#5
Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 6
And there's, like, a bunch of vaginas, too.
#6
Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 7
- Really? - Yeah. Uh, hashtag "Sara Pearson did it,"
#7
Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 8 #8 Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 9 #9 Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 10
It's rumored he's being pushed into early retirement.
#10
Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 11
He did mysteriously discover the spray paint can
#11
Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 12
And a nasty one, too.
#12
Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 13
was based on the penis of her ex-boyfriend,
#13
Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 14
She was down in San Diego with her family, so, I'm not buying this fan theory.
#14
Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 15
at the kegger at Rachel Balducci's grandmother's house,
#15
Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 16
I was chilling, Dylan and the Wayback Boys were right there,
#16
Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 17
Yo, Nana's party was insane.
#17
Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 18 #18 Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 19 #19 Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 20
The boys all deny planning the dicks at Nana's.
#20
Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 21 #21 Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 22 #22 Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 23
Ten fifty-nine, from behind the couch, they're still talking.
#23
Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 24
Hold up. Are we for sure thinking Tuesday, though?
#24
Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 25
"If the cops show up, we just run."
#25
Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 26
When he goes to Ganj and Lucas, we can hear her for a moment.
#26
Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 27 #27 Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 28
by giving him a heart attack.
#28
Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 29
But, "I hope we don't kill him"?
#29
Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 30 #30 Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 31
This brand, Crimpton, was discontinued in 1996.
#31
Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 32 #32 Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 33
Sorry things went like that the other day.
#33
Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 34
That is too good. That's too perfect. He's totally the type of person...
#34
Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 35
Oh, no, no, no. No, no, no, I'm not...
#35
Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 36 #36 Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 37
and while we can't place Dylan with the can,
#37
Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 38
I think if he did the dicks, he's letting it all fall on Dylan.
#38
Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 39
There are a few holes in both timelines, but the entire night is accounted for.
#39
Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 40 #40 Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 41
Gabi. I or Y?
#41
Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 42
We see the can is still in the bushes here at 11:35.
#42
Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 43
- No way. - Yeah!
#43
Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 44
Isn't that the same beer he was drinking earlier?
#44
Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 45
At 12:04, Matt Zordich tries spraying Carl Wolf.
#45
Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 46
Fuck the police!
#46
Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 47
the videos from Nana's party allowed us to narrow our pool of suspects.
#47
Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 48
They have to shake 20 times?
#48
Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 49
we had to shake it again.
#49
Recap of American Vandal Season 1 Episode 5 (S01E05) - 50
So, the first car hit would have splatter.
#50