The Keepers

A tip line yields compelling stories that point the group's investigation to two more men who might have been involved in Sister Catherine's murder.

Mouse over thumbnail for slideshow

Or scroll and see one by one:

I didn't get the impression that-- That Maskell was the kind of guy

#2 #3

and she looked at me panicked and said, "I never said that."

#4

We became engaged at Christmastime.

#5

And Ed, at that point, got violent.

#6 #7

Right away, I'm getting a flashback.

#8

So, I started putting that as another piece to the puzzle

#9 #10

I mean, he was arrested for car theft two years after Cathy was murdered,

#11

And they found those rolls in the car when they found the car.

#12

I felt like he didn't buy that for me.

#13

We don't have anything to tell you." We sort of respected that.

#14

and his family as being involved in Sister Cathy's murder...

#15

who they believed was involved that night.

#16

He said to my mother, "You wanna know why I drink?

#17

Her car was parked right there in the opening of that driveway.

#18

-Yeah. -So, I've got you on speaker.

#19 #20 #21

William Charles Schmidt.

#22

Back then, we're talking early '60s,

#23

I asked him, "Ronnie, where you been?"

#24

After the nun was murdered, he was obsessed with it.

#25

and I worked the night shift. I worked 4:30 to 1.

#26 #27 #28

And I go, "What are you talking about?" And he hung up.

#29

and saw Cathy's body.

#30 #31

What's the word? Like, the secret to a 33-year marriage...

#32

and what they were saying to me.

#33 #34 #35

but to give it some brightness they put a little foil backing.

#36

and that it was not an expensive piece of jewelry.

#37

I was doing the dishes one night watching the six o'clock news,

#38

We never, ever once discussed it.

#39

And I was in her apartment and my Uncle Bill was there.

#40

And while Bobby was shooting the gun in the woods to keep me occupied...

#41

I can just tell you what I saw, how I saw it, who I saw it with,

#42

[Gemma] Okay. Place on something, something, bake for ten to 15 minutes.

#43

Marilyn... is taking her time,

#44

Hi. Is it Marilyn?

#45 #46

[Tom] I have heard a lot of indirect stuff about Edgar and Bill

#47 #48

You didn't know if he was gonna be the good guy or the bad guy.

#49 #50