S5 E8
Status
Ended
Network
FOX
SEASON
VIEW ALL EPISODE

Season 5  "The Decision"  5x8

Aired 8 years ago - Feb 23, 2016

Reagan causes chaos between Nick and Winston when she tells them she’ll sleep with just one of them in an attempt to challenge the guys’ indecisiveness. Meanwhile, Schmidt is reunited with his college frenemy, Benjamin, when looking at wedding venues with Cece.

Mouse over thumbnail for slideshow

Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 1
In that case, the gentleman politely...
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 2
Perhaps I'm dealing with a dingus.
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 3
I was put in an awkward situation,
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 4
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 5
the vacant warehouse for the wedding venue?
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 6
We could do this all day, but I have actual feelings for her.
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 7
You knew I had a crush on Cindy De La Garza,
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 8
You called dibs... and I screwed up.
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 9
You'll be having Winston.
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 10
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 11
I'm so sorry. I'm just feeling a little insecure about my body
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 12
The second I said it, I was like...
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 13
Well, I'm not even close to giving up.
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 14
Ah. Mr. Schmidt.
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 15
You see, Winston had dibs on Cindy De La Garza since the fifth grade,
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 16
- Well, no, it's a story about... - But you guys
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 17
But now
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 18
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 19
Mm.
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 20
It's probably not even available.
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 21
In April?
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 22
What? Schmittyballs?
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 23
while I was already dancing.
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 24
- We... are booking The Lisbon. - We are?
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 25
- Right. By crime. - I could tell you
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 26
Really?
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 27
Okay.
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 28
Hello? Hello, Nick?
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 29
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 30
- she can't do that. - No, no, she did that. I'm so sorry.
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 31
Bitch, we're gonna have more white linen
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 32
Our wedding is gonna be so... big...
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 33
- for the second time. - Maybe it's just us, but we love Pixar.
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 34
at the Vietnam Memorial.
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 35
Between family members? I mean, that's...
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 36
And how are you still shaving?
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 37
- That's not gonna happen. - It is gonna happen.
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 38
- Oh, my God. - We got to turn the tables on Reagan,
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 39
$15,000!
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 40
Yes!
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 41
but yes, we have made a decision.
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 42
Okay, well, the logic is bulletproof.
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 43
That is both a lot and a little,
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 44
But what I should have said was,
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 45
- You like Aly. - Yes.
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 46
What should I do? I don't know what to do.
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 47
but obviously, we will not be making love tonight.
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 48
Well, both rooms have a lot of interesting possibilities.
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 49
I just need... two minutes tops.
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 50

Or scroll and see one by one:

Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 2
Perhaps I'm dealing with a dingus.
#2
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 3
I was put in an awkward situation,
#3
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 4 #4 Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 5
the vacant warehouse for the wedding venue?
#5
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 6
We could do this all day, but I have actual feelings for her.
#6
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 7
You knew I had a crush on Cindy De La Garza,
#7
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 8
You called dibs... and I screwed up.
#8
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 9
You'll be having Winston.
#9
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 10 #10 Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 11
I'm so sorry. I'm just feeling a little insecure about my body
#11
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 12
The second I said it, I was like...
#12
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 13
Well, I'm not even close to giving up.
#13
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 14
Ah. Mr. Schmidt.
#14
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 15
You see, Winston had dibs on Cindy De La Garza since the fifth grade,
#15
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 16
- Well, no, it's a story about... - But you guys
#16
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 17
But now
#17
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 18 #18 Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 19
Mm.
#19
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 20
It's probably not even available.
#20
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 21
In April?
#21
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 22
What? Schmittyballs?
#22
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 23
while I was already dancing.
#23
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 24
- We... are booking The Lisbon. - We are?
#24
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 25
- Right. By crime. - I could tell you
#25
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 26
Really?
#26
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 27
Okay.
#27
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 28
Hello? Hello, Nick?
#28
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 29 #29 Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 30
- she can't do that. - No, no, she did that. I'm so sorry.
#30
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 31
Bitch, we're gonna have more white linen
#31
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 32
Our wedding is gonna be so... big...
#32
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 33
- for the second time. - Maybe it's just us, but we love Pixar.
#33
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 34
at the Vietnam Memorial.
#34
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 35
Between family members? I mean, that's...
#35
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 36
And how are you still shaving?
#36
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 37
- That's not gonna happen. - It is gonna happen.
#37
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 38
- Oh, my God. - We got to turn the tables on Reagan,
#38
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 39
$15,000!
#39
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 40
Yes!
#40
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 41
but yes, we have made a decision.
#41
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 42
Okay, well, the logic is bulletproof.
#42
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 43
That is both a lot and a little,
#43
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 44
But what I should have said was,
#44
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 45
- You like Aly. - Yes.
#45
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 46
What should I do? I don't know what to do.
#46
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 47
but obviously, we will not be making love tonight.
#47
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 48
Well, both rooms have a lot of interesting possibilities.
#48
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 49
I just need... two minutes tops.
#49
Recap of New Girl Season 5 Episode 8 (S05E08) - 50 #50